EPOXI Review - 29 September 2010 Liens Resolved - 12 Nov 2010 DIF-M-HRIV-3/4-EPOXI-MARS-V1.0 ============================== o The dataset.cat file has an incomplete sentence at the end of the "Required Reading" section. >> Done. o Supply the ASCII equivalents of all PDF documents in the document/ directory. >> SBN said PDF/A was acceptable. Done. o All labels should indicate that geometry parameters were calculated at the midpoint of the observation time. >> No. We've been noting this in dataset.cat and archive SIS since DI! o Kelly Fast submitted this list of typos with her report: catalog/dataset.cat o Should note that required reading files detailed here are included in the document/ directory of the data set. o Is it possible to add a web link to the DI/EPOXI documentation data set (DI-C-HRII/HRIV/MRI/ITS-6-DOC-SET-V3.0)? >> Done. Added link to http://pds.nasa.gov. catalog/epoxi.cat o The section "EPOCh Marc Obs" reuses the wording from the Earth obs but does not replace "Earth" with "Mars" in a few locations. >> Done. catalog/personnel.cat o Would be more useful to the user if roles are present for all o Consider including more of the EPOCh Mars team? >> Done. Added T.Livengood. document/epoch_mars_sequence_2009.pdf o A leftover "Earth" should be "Mars" in the very first "Description" row. >> Done. document/epoxi_sis.pdf o Page 6: "see by Hampton" should be "see Hampton" o Page 9: "remove sensing" should be "remote sensing" o This document says there should be a calibration.cat file but there is not such file in this data set. >> Done. o Richard Chen will submit a list of standards compliance issues via email: catalog/epoxi.cat o Target MOA-2009-BLG-266 needs a TARGET.CAT. >> At the review, SBN showed a catalog file for this target is included in the DIF-X-HRIV-5-EPOXI-EXOPLANETS-PHOT-V1.0 data set. The file needs to be submitted to EN. document/pdsdd_epoxi.ful o NAME = EPOXI:ADC_SATURATED_PIXEL_COUNT (and the other EPOXI:) needs quotes. We (SBN and EN) may want to add "EPOXI:*" to the overall data dictionary. >> Done. data/.../*.lbl o INSTRUMENT_MODE_ID = 2 should be "2" >> Done. o FILTER_NUMBER = 2 should be "2" >> Done. o INSTRUMENT_TEMPERATURE_POINT: someone "should" open an SCR for values used by DI/EPOXI. >> SBN declined this recommendation during the review. o INSTRUMENT_VOLTAGE_POINT: someone "should" open an SCR ffor values used by DI/EPOXI. >> SBN declined this recommendation the peer review. o S. McLaughlin submitted a list of liens: catalog/dif.cat o Change instances of Doc Set "V2.0" to "V3.0". >> Done. catalog/epoxi.cat o Change start/stop dates to "2009-09-30" for "Checkout after HRI Turnoff" on 2010 DOY 273 in the mission activities list. >> Done. document/epoch_mars_seq_2009.pdf o Change unit from "ms" to "sec" for the Sequence Time column (#2) in the Pointing section of this document (pages 1 through 7). >> Done. General Liens ------------- o Check all EPOXI data sets for the FITS header errors listed in Kelly Fast's presentation; fix them as needed. >> Added clarifications of keywords in question to errata.txt. o Note that no link was provided from the review page or dataset.html pages to the DI/EPOXI documentation set, so this was effectively unavailable to the reviewers. >> DI/EPOXI doc set *is* noted in Required Reading section of dataset.cat. These data are accepted for certification.