EPOXI Review - 29 September 2010
  
      
DIF-X-HRIV-5-EPOXI-EXOPLANETS-PHOT-V1.0
=======================================
  
o  To the dataset.cat file section "Related Data Sets", add a line to refer
   users to the PDS home page to find these data sets, and include the base URL.
   >>  Done.
 
o  Query whether it is possible to republish the Rich Barry paper as part of
   the data set, and include it if so.
   >>  Done.  R.Barry provided a report of his PSF work.  See
       epoxi_hriv_psfs.pdf in DOCUMENT.
 
o  Add uncertainties to the measurements.
   >>  Done.  D.Deming summarized photom errors for each target.  
       See epoch_trans_obs.pdf in DOCUMENT.
  
o  Need a summary of the calibration steps applied, and differences in
   calibration from target to target. Suggested: a table listing target vs.
   processing steps applied.
   >>  Done.  D.Deming summarized the steps applied to each target.
       See epoch_trans_obs.pdf in DOCUMENT.
 
o  Document which PSF was used for which light curve.
   >>  Done.  D.Deming stated each target star was used to make its own PSF.
       See epoch_trans_obs.pdf in DOCUMENT.
 
o  Richard Chen will submit a list of standards compliance issues via email:
 
   catalog/epoxi.cat
   o  Target MOA-2009-BLG-266 needs a TARGET.CAT.
      >>  At the review, SBN showed a catalog file for this target is included 
          in the DIF-X-HRIV-5-EPOXI-EXOPLANETS-PHOT-V1.0 data set.  The file 
          needs to be submitted to EN.
    
  catalog/dataset.cat
  o  DATA_SET_DESC has [KLASSENETAL2006] but file has no REFERENCE_KEY_ID = 
     KLASSENETAL2006.  
     >>  During review, it was noted that [KLASSENETAL2006] is a typo.
         Should be [KLAASENETAL2006].
     >>  Done.
         
o  S. McLaughlin submitted a list of liens:
  
   catalog/dif.cat 
   o  Change instances of Doc Set "V2.0" to "V3.0".
      >>  Done.
   
   catalog/epoxi.cat
   o  Change start/stop dates to "2009-09-30" for "Checkout after HRI Turnoff" 
      on 2010 DOY 273 in the mission activities list.
      >> Done.
 

General Liens
-------------
  
o  Check all EPOXI data sets for the FITS header errors listed in Kelly Fast's
   presentation; fix them as needed.
   >>  N/A.
    
o  Note that no link was provided from the review page or dataset.html pages
   to the DI/EPOXI documentation set, so this was effectively unavailable to
   the reviewers.
   >>  N/A.
  
 
These data are rejected for certification pending the additions listed above.