Listed below are the liens/RIDs that were found at the PDS/PSA February 2016 review of the Prelanding thru Escort 1 phases of the Rosetta mission. Even though this particular data set may have not participated in the review, it uses the same pipeline and so the liens likely apply here as well. Please take note that some issues may be resolved, while others are not. If any other issues are discovered please let the PDS-SBN know. It is expected that a fully lien resolved version will be produced during post mission ops and archived with an incremented data set version number. 1)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-101-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN-0087, numerous locations Title: MID-EICD Typographical Errors Description: Typographical errors which do not affect data analysis or interpretation but fixing would aid document clarity. Proposed solution by reviewer: Reviewer will provide scan of MID-EICD document with errors highlighted and solutions proposed. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 2)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-102-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID_IWF-TN-0087, page 17, figure. Title: MID-EICD TGT01 height Description: TGT01 height h not given, but labelled. Proposed solution by reviewer: Add height or delete h label if height not useful. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: The height is roughly 0.7 microns. It will be added. 3)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-103-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN-0087, page 17, 7 lines from bottom. Title: MID-EICD Up to date 1 Description: States "presumably contain" Proposed solution by reviewer: Bring up to date with actual content. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 4)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-104-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID_IWF-TN-0087, numerous locations Title: MID-EICD Section 2.4-2.5 Description: Many references to information in Section 2.4 should actually refer to Section 2.5. Proposed solution by reviewer: Where required update references. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 5)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-105-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN-0087, p22, line 8 Title: MID-EICD Up to date 2 Description: States "it is planned to" Proposed solution by reviewer: Bring up to date with actual content. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 6)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-106-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN-0087, p25, hyperlink 7 lines from bottom. Title: MID-EICD BCR-STM Web link Description: Web link gives 404 error. Proposed solution by reviewer: Find new location of information and update link or - better - include information in archive. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: It will be changed the link. Ok to add the information also to the archive. 7)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-107-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p26, line 10 Title: MID-EICD voidpixels Description: Statement is contradictory/confusing Proposed solution by reviewer: Update statement to confirm whether voidpixels should be zero or 32767. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 8)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-109-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p29, table entry 8, MIDCALIB file in CALIB directory. Title: MID-EICD Calibration table line 8 PIEZO HV Description: Calibration factors for Piezo HV voltage monitor in table do not match value in MIDCALIB file. Proposed solution by reviewer: Determine correct value and update files accordingly. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: EAICD has to be updated 9)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-110-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p29, table entry 32, MIDCALIB file in CALIB directory, LIN_STAGE_POS value in data files Title: MID-EICD Calibration table line 32 LIN_STAGE_POS Description: Calibration factors for Linear Stage LVDT position do not allow Target position to be derived from data files. Converted voltages do not agree with Table 1 in Coordinate Systems Document. Proposed solution by reviewer: Check and update calibration tables if error is real. Suggested values are OFFSET = 16.4, SCALE_FACTOR = -1.8221. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 10)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-111-JH Dataset: ALL? Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p30, line 3, CATINFO.TXT, CATALOG Dir. Title: MID-EICD Archive Desc 1 Description: Missing entry for SOFTWARE.CAT in CATINFO file, but shown in listing in MID-EICD. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update file or remove from document listing. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 11)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-112-JH Dataset: ALL? Location: MID-IWF-TN0087,p30, line 10, CATALOG Dir. Title: MID-EICD Archive Desc 2 Description: REF.CAT is actually called REFERENCE.CAT Proposed solution by reviewer: Update document Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 12)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-113-JH Dataset: ALL? Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p30, line 16, CATALOG Dir. Title: MID-EICD Archive Desc 3 Description: PERSON.CAT missing in directory. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update directory or document. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 13)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-114-JH Dataset: ALL? Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p30, section 3.4.2.4.1 Title: MID-EICD Archive Desc 4 Description: GEO* files missing from directory. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update document Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 14)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-115-JH Dataset: ALL? Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p31, section 3.4.2.5 Title: MID-EICD Archive Desc 5 Description: SOFTINFO.TXT file listed in documentation, not present in dataset. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update document. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 15)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-116-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p116, mid_browse IDL software Title: MID-BROWSE Description: Red square when viewing FSC files is often in the wrong place or plotted outside plot window. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update software to only plot red square when region of frequency scan containing the maximum is present on the screen. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Accepted 16)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-117-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p117, section 5.2.2 para 1 Title: PDS Library Changes Description: Statement that several bug fixes and improvements made to READPDS library for use with MIDAS software means that user has no idea whether independently obtained READPDS code will work accurately with MIDAS data. Proposed solution by reviewer: Provide listing of bug fixes or changes made to standard READPDS code for use with MIDAS data. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: It will be added a log of changes. Accepted. 17)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-118-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0087, p118, Appendix 6 Title: Appendix 6 Listings Description: Listing does not agree with actual files found in directories in archive - see MID-EICD Archive Desc 1-5 Proposed solution by reviewer: Update listing to reflect reality or update reality to reflect listing! Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 18)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-119-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0029, numerous locations Title: MID-COORD TBD/TBR/TBC Description: Lots of TBD/TBR and TBC entries (including in figures) which require updating. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update entries and/or add to Table on page 3. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 19)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-120-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0029, numerous locations Title: MID-COORD Typographical Errors Description: Typographical errors which do not affect data analysis or interpretation but fixing would aid document clarity. Proposed solution by reviewer: Reviewer will provide scan of MID-EICD document with errors highlighted and solutions proposed. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 20)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-121-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0029, page 6, Figure 3 Title: MID-COORD Figure 3 Description: Figure 3 contains numerous labels which are not defined in the text. Proposed solution by reviewer: Define labels in text. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 21)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-122-JH Dataset: ALL Location: MID-IWF-TN0029, page 9, last paragraph Title: MID-COORD Up to date 1 Description: Paragraph states that the figures do not reflect the latest status of the mechanical design. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update figure if worth it, otherwise remove statement to avoid confusion. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 22)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-123-JH Dataset: ALL Location: BCR_STM Images Title: BCR_STM Orientation Description: Loading images in IDL based on description provided in MID-IWF-TN0087 results in image flipped vertically. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update documentation to specify correct orientation of images. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Presumably accepted 23)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-124-JH Dataset: RO-D-MIDAS-3-PRL-SAMPLES-V1.0 Location: Supplied files Title: TGH Missing Description: Some TGH files (e.g. TGH_0409522_1432400_16) missing from supplied PRL dataset despite being required for e.g. IMG_1426610_1429710_040_ZS) Proposed solution by reviewer: Check automatic dataset assembling code if used, or ensure completeness of datasets. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: To be investigated 24)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-125 Dataset: ALL Location: All/Most data files Title: PDS Level Description: Although many files, or their labels, contain the information required to calibrate them, the actual data (e.g. Z height) is not calibrated. Proposed solution by reviewer: If this problem means the provided data does not meet the PDS level 3 standard then process and update data accordingly. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Accepted 25)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-126-JH Dataset: ALL Location: All TGH files Title: TGH Giada flux Description: Giada flux information not included in TGH files, despite this being mentioned in the MID_EICD document. Proposed solution by reviewer: Update TGH files accordingly, to include flux information, or update MID_EICD to specify that the flux information may not always be present and can be dervied from other instrument archive data sets. Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: Accepted 26)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-101-AS Dataset: ro-c-midas-3-esc1-samples-v1.0 Location: Image data Title: Software issue Description: The image data can only be viewed correctly in commercially available or non-PDS software Proposed solution by reviewer: Convert images into a form that does not rely on a commercial format Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: "No problem with the format, it is acceptable within PDS V3 but, the values does not make sense. PDS viewers cannot reproduce the image as displayed by the proprietary software. It is not clear why. This must be investigated and resolved. The data cannot be archived if it is not accurately described by the PDS label alone. To be further discussed offline." "It is readable by several sw packages. The team will investigate why the values look wrong and solve it. Also to be followed offline" 27)Reference ID (RID): RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-102-AS Dataset: ro-d-midas-3-prl-samples-v1.0 Location: Image data Title: Software issue Description: The image data can only be viewed correctly in commercially available or non-PDS software Proposed solution by reviewer: Convert images into a form that does not rely on a commercial format Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: See RID RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-101-AS and See RID RO-AR-RID-MIDAS-101-AS 28)Reference ID (RID): ro-c-midas-102-RE Dataset: ro-c-midas-3-esc1-samples-v1.0 Location: document/mid_eicd.pdf Title: MIDAS PDF Description: " - p.23, bottom: suggest alphabetizing the list of {data type} - p.24, FSC/possiblevalues: instead of ""001..999"", digit 3 seems to be hex (e.g. 00..99, 0-F) - p.24, LIN/possiblevalues: instead of ""001..999"", digit 3 seems to be hex - p.24, IMG/possiblevalues: ""S1"" is not listed as a value in extra table IMG - DAQ channel value (img_1504123_1507000_009_s1.img) - should document missing value - p.36, suggest alphabetizing table 4.2.5 - p.86, the COLUMNs after START_BYTE 41 do not match the actual file - p.110, START_BYTE = 92 and subsequent START_BYTEs are low/off by 1 — EL: 92 should have been 93 - p.113, START_BYTEs are off, as are two of the BYTES=" Proposed solution by reviewer: see description Review board discussion outcome and Instrument team response: From Engineering node at PDS. Not discussed in scientific review meeting