SDU-C/CAL-NAVCAM-2-NEXT-TEMPEL1-V1.0
====================================


Result: Certified; accepted pending lien resolution.


Liens
=====

o Please add acronym list to documentation.

o catalog/navcam.cat 
  -  Says wavelengths in the filter table are in nanometers, but most of 
     them appear to be in Angstroms.  The notation is generally confusing for "blocking"
     and needs to be explained. (Transmission curves elsewhere may contain better, or 
     better-formatted, information and could be referenced.)
  -  line 53, change ";" to ","
  -  line 230  "hold" -> "held"
  -  line 753  Define E (encounter time). Please standardize the usage between
     documents (T is used elsewhere, e.g., in next.txt).
  -  line 778  "E-3d" -> "E-3 days"

o Add the corrected compression table to the data set.

o catalog/next.cat 
  -  Has gaps in the mission phase table.  These should be explained, preferably
     by documenting the idle interstitial days in the phase table.  Also check the 
     "Spacecraft Operations Type" values in this table; and it would probably be a 
     good idea to proof everything in the table.
  -  One version ahead of the other datasets'.
  -  line 30   "15.February" -> "15 February"
  -  line 89   "200X" -> "2006"
  -  line 122  "CIDA on" -> "CIDA was on"
  -  line 123  "data taken" -> "data were taken"
  -  line 126  "Performed navigation maneuvers" -> "Navigation maneuvers were 
     performed"
  -  line 142  T is used here for the time of encounter, but E was used in 
     navcam.cat. Please standardize this usage. Also, please define
     T (or E).
  -  line 166, remove "." after 15
  -  line 189  "26.March" -> "25 March"
  -  line 192: "earth" -> "Earth"

o catalog/dataset.cat 
  -  Doesn't mention the "Approach" and "Encounter" phases mentioned in the 
     mission catalog. The mapping from these names to the abbreviations used in file 
     names should be mentioned in the mission catalog.
  -  "Data product type and overview" and "Parameters" sections, there 
     are paragraphs for both the raw and calibrated data, but only the relevant
     ones should be retained.
  -  lines 132 and 133: 8-s and 6s, make the wording consistent, and consistent with 
     15s in line 142
  -  line 200: insrument -> instrument
  -  line 341, move coma from after "not" to after "scale"
  -  line 365  "on on" -> "on"
  -  line 424  Consider adding a phrase like this for clarification: "These reasons 
     for missing images are explained below."
  -  Has host ID of "SDU", but this is "N/A" in the instrument file.
     This discrepancy needs to be resolved.

o Change "decalibration" to terminology less likely to confuse users.

o If possible, please provide a table of X, Y position (or RA, Dec) of the comet in each 
  image. Tony Farnham says he can supply this table.

o VOLDESC.CAT is missing RECORD_TYPE.

o The document/samples directory needs to be either filled or removed. If possible, 
  please add a browse facility with thumbnails for at least the encounter images.

o catalog/reference.cat
  -  BROWNLEEETAL2003 is missing author F. Horz
  -  After first author, initials precede last name, e.g. for
     "BELTONETAL2011":
     REFERENCE_DESC = "Belton, M.J.S., Meech, K.J., Chesley, S., ..." should be
     REFERENCE_DESC = "Belton, M.J.S., K.J. Meech, S. Chesley, ..."
  -  DUXBURYETAL2004 should be DUXBURYETAL2004B
  -  missing references from other datasets' reference.cat (which may be
     desired):
     SEMENOVETAL2004B, ECONOMOUETAL2011, GREENETAL2004, TUZZOLINO1994

o aareadme.txt 
  -  line 23  "considered and integral" -> "considered an integral" [in all three
     aareadme.txt files]

o calib/navcam_activity_log.lbl
  -  line 70  "the the" -> "to the"
  -  line 240 "irrlevant" -> "irrelevant"

o catalog/sdu.cat
  -  line 134  "15.February" -> "15 February"

o document/docinfo.txt
  -  Lines 48 and 49 are duplicates with one word different. Delete one
     of these lines

o document/nc_fits_sis.htm
  -  lines 29 and 1031    "Pypeline" -> "Pipeline"

o calib/navcam_activity_log.lbl
  -  line 70  "the the" -> "to the"
  -  line 240 "irrlevant" -> "irrelevant"

o Note that there is a reference in the next, preflight data set that should be added
  to the reference list for these data sets.

o data/*fit and *lbl
  - Compute and add the Sun azimuth and elevation, where possible, to the FITS headers
    and PDS labels.  Include definitions of those terms in the documentation.
    This lien was imposed internally by the NExT team with the approval of SBN on
    10 Jan 2012.