SDU-C/D-DFMI-2/3-NEXT-TEMPEL1-V1.0 ================================== Result: Certified; plan email delta review of revised data table after lien resolution ######################################################################## Summary: Data set is ready for delta-review; no liens remain to be resolved. All liens were either resolved or found not applicable to this data set (2012-05-15 BTCarcich). ######################################################################## Liens ===== Three sections of liens, copied from the original peer review of these data set, are listed below: Unresolved; Resolved; Unresolvable. Within Resolved liens section, each lien is delimited by a line of seventy- two underscores. The original lien follows the underscores preceded by a single hash character (#) at the start of each major section or subsection of the lien. The description of the resolution of the lien follows, set off by the characters: DONE For the Unresolved Liens, the hash and DONE characters are replaced by query (?) and IGNORED. ######################################################################## ### Unresolved liens: ######################################################################## ### None remaining ######################################################################## ### Resolved liens: ######################################################################## ________________________________________________________________________ # DATA/DFMI{CRU,ENC}_YYMMDD*.LBL [self-generated lien; missed by reviewers] HIGH and LOW were swapped in DFMI EDR data TABLE labels for acoustic sensor channel counts. This goes back to prime mission 81P/Wild 2 data set. DONE: corrected COLUMN NAMEs and DESCRIPTIONs ________________________________________________________________________ # DOCUMENT/DFMICAL.* [self-generated lien; missed by reviewers] HIGH and LOW were assigned to wrong meaning (to threshold instead of gain/sensitivity) in Table 1 in the PDF. DONE: Corrected ASCII_DOCUMENT DFMICAL.ASC and made note in DFMICAL.LBL. DFMICAL.PDF was not changed. ________________________________________________________________________ # PVDF data is not corrected for overflows, but it should be. DONE: Added DATA/TEMPEL1/PVDF_UNROLL_AND_RATES.TAB table with unrolled counts and count rates for PVDF counter for 9P/Tempel 1 data only. ________________________________________________________________________ # The data set does not include rates, but it would be very helpful if it did at, say, 1-second intervals (or relevant time interval) for flyby. Please add these if possible. DONE: in same table as overflows, above. ________________________________________________________________________ # There is no Software Interface Specification. SBN will find a good example for Brian to follow in creating one. DONE: SIS-equivalent files were available, but appararently not noticed by the reviewers. Looked at SIS file from data set generated by the reviewer as a sample but determined that that format provides limited SIS functionality compared to existing NExT-provided DFMI documentation. Added SIS Table Of Contents file, with SIS in filename, and pointing to existing SIS-equivalent files. Also rearranged files in document/ to make important files more prominent and likely to be found. ________________________________________________________________________ # If possible, please include an events table to list events that might affect the data table, like thruster firings, at least for the flyby. Alternately, add a column to the data table to indicate trustworthiness of the data. DONE: see data/sffextract.lbl ________________________________________________________________________ # SBN will provide support as needed to convert complex documents with graphics to a PDF/A format for archival storage in anticipation of migration to PDS4. DONE: Not needed; multi-image HTML documents moved to subdirectories to reduce clutter. ________________________________________________________________________ # catalog/next.cat # One version ahead of the other datasets'. DONE ________________________________________________________________________ # data/datainfo.txt: # piezoelectrictric -> piezoelectric # alphnumeric -> alphanumeric DONE ________________________________________________________________________ # catalog/next.cat # Has gaps in the mission phase table. These should be explained, preferably by documenting the idle interstitial days in the phase table. Also check the "Spacecraft Operations Type" values in this table; and it would probably be a good idea to proof everything in the table. # line 30 "15.February" -> "15 February" # line 89 "200X" -> "2006" # line 122 "CIDA on" -> "CIDA was on" # line 123 "data taken" -> "data were taken" # line 126 "Performed navigation maneuvers" -> "Navigation maneuvers were performed" # line 142 T is used here for the time of encounter, but E was used in navcam.cat. Please standardize this usage. Also, please define T (or E). # line 166, remove "." after 15 # line 189 "26.March" -> "25 March" # line 192: "earth" -> "Earth" DONE: typos fixed; phase table rewritten ________________________________________________________________________ # catalog/dataset.cat # line 402 "on on" -> "on" DONE. ________________________________________________________________________ # VOLDESC.CAT is missing RECORD_TYPE. DONE: fixed ________________________________________________________________________ # catalog/reference.cat # BROWNLEEETAL2003 is missing author F. Horz # After first author, initials precede last name, e.g. for "BELTONETAL2011": REFERENCE_DESC = "Belton, M.J.S., Meech, K.J., Chesley, S., ..." should be REFERENCE_DESC = "Belton, M.J.S., K.J. Meech, S. Chesley, ..." # DUXBURYETAL2004 should be DUXBURYETAL2004B DONE: fixed in all data sets ________________________________________________________________________ # catalog/sdu.cat # line 134 "15.February" -> "15 February" DONE: fixed ________________________________________________________________________ # aareadme.txt # line 23 "considered and integral" -> "considered an integral" [in all three aareadme.txt files] DONE: typo fixed ________________________________________________________________________ # document/docinfo.txt # Lines 102 and 103 are duplicates with one word different. Delete one of these lines DONE: typo fixed ######################################################################## ### Unresolvable liens ######################################################################## ________________________________________________________________________ ? catalog/dataset.cat ? Has host ID of "SDU", but this is "N/A" in the instrument file. This discrepancy needs to be resolved. IGNORED: N/A was not present as the host ID of any catalog file; lien typo?